Home › Men’s Health Library

Do You Have to Try Pills First Before a Penile Implant?

Many men arrive at Dr. Gheiler’s office believing there is a required order: pills first, then a vacuum device, then injections, and only if all of that fails, an implant. That order is not a rule, and it is not what the guideline says.

The choice is yours to make with your urologist

The American Urological Association’s erectile dysfunction guideline is built on shared decision making. It says every man should be told about all the treatments that are safe for him, including the more invasive and less reversible ones, as possible first choices. Then he and his urologist choose based on what fits his life, his anatomy and his goals. Nothing in it requires a man to try and fail pills, a vacuum device or injections before he can choose an implant.

What the options are

Four treatments are in common use.

  • Pills. Taken by mouth. They need working nerves and reasonably healthy blood vessels to do anything at all.
  • Vacuum device. An external pump with a constriction ring. Nothing is implanted.
  • Injections. Medication injected into the penis before sex, acting on the blood vessels directly.
  • Inflatable penile implant. Two cylinders inside the penis, a small pump concealed in the scrotum, and a fluid reservoir inside the abdomen. You squeeze the pump for an erection and press a valve when you are finished. Everything sits inside the body, and nothing shows from the outside.

Because the implant is a mechanical device, it produces an erection whatever caused the erectile dysfunction. That matters most to men whose nerves or blood vessels are damaged, such as men who have had prostate cancer surgery and men with long-standing diabetes.

What the satisfaction data shows

In published studies comparing men on different treatments, those with implants were more satisfied than men on pills or injections (Rajpurkar and Dhabuwala, Journal of Urology, 2003), and so were their partners (Kucuk and colleagues, Andrology, 2016).

Neither study was a randomized controlled trial, so read them as a strong signal, not proof. Rajpurkar and Dhabuwala compared patients who were already on each treatment, and they measured patients only. Kucuk and colleagues was a retrospective study that included 22 implant patients and measured partners as well as patients.

Why Dr. Gheiler recommends the inflatable type

Dr. Gheiler recommends the inflatable implant. It is concealed, it is flaccid when you are not using it, and it behaves like a normal erection when you are. A malleable implant stays semi-rigid all the time. It has a place in special situations, for example when a man’s hand dexterity would make a pump difficult to operate, but it is not what Dr. Gheiler recommends for the typical patient.

Before you decide

If pills seem to have stopped working, make sure they had a fair trial before you conclude anything: the right dose, taken the right way, on more than one occasion, with your blood sugar, testosterone and blood pressure checked. Many men conclude that pills failed them when the pills were never used correctly.

Do not wait indefinitely, either. Long stretches without erections can contribute to loss of penile length and elasticity. If your erections are gone entirely, that is a reason to see a urologist sooner rather than later.

An implant is not a penalty for failing at other treatments. It is one of four legitimate options, and the man having the surgery is the one who chooses it, at whatever point in his life he chooses it.

Frequently asked questions about trying pills first

Do I have to try pills before I can get a penile implant?

No. The American Urological Association erectile dysfunction guideline is built on shared decision making. It says every man should be told about all the treatments that are safe for him, including more invasive and less reversible ones, as possible first choices. Nothing in it requires failing pills, a vacuum device or injections first.

What treatments are available for erectile dysfunction?

Four are in common use: pills, a vacuum device, injections into the penis, and an inflatable penile implant. You and your urologist choose based on your life, your anatomy and your goals.

Are men with penile implants more satisfied than men on pills or injections?

In published studies comparing men on different treatments, men with implants were more satisfied than men on pills or injections, and so were their partners. Neither study was a randomized controlled trial, so the finding is a strong signal, not proof.

How do I know whether pills really failed?

Make sure they had a fair trial first: the right dose, taken the right way, on more than one occasion, with your blood sugar, testosterone and blood pressure checked. Many men conclude that pills failed when they were never used correctly.

See all FAQs →

References: (1) Burnett AL, Nehra A, Breau RH, et al. Erectile dysfunction: AUA guideline. J Urol. 2018;200(3):633–641. doi:10.1016/j.juro.2018.05.004. (2) Rajpurkar A, Dhabuwala CB. Comparison of satisfaction rates and erectile function in patients treated with sildenafil, intracavernous prostaglandin E1 and penile implant surgery for erectile dysfunction in urology practice. J Urol. 2003;170(1):159–163. doi:10.1097/01.ju.0000072524.82345.6d. (3) Kucuk EV, Tahra A, Bindayi A, Onol FF. Erectile dysfunction patients are more satisfied with penile prosthesis implantation compared with tadalafil and intracavernosal injection treatments. Andrology. 2016;4(5):952–956. doi:10.1111/andr.12237.

This article is patient education and does not replace a medical consultation. Individual results and experiences vary. Discuss your specific case with your urologist.

Talk through your options

Dr. Gheiler will go through all four treatments with you and what fits your situation. You do not have to fail anything first.

Private and confidential from your first call: these are problems our office treats every day, with discretion and respect.

Call (305) 822-7227
☎ (305) 822-7227Book a Consult